Dominant Logic in the Car Industry: Why Companies Hold On to Broken Assumptions
Why do carmakers cling to broken assumptions? Data on German car boards since 2012 shows how dominant logic lives in the people at the top.
Why do carmakers cling to broken assumptions? Data on German car boards since 2012 shows how dominant logic lives in the people at the top.
When an assumption behind a business model breaks, most companies respond with bad strategy. This post argues that broken assumptions are the best possible starting point for good strategy, provided they are treated as a diagnosis. It applies Richard Rumelt’s kernel of good strategy – diagnosis, guiding policy, coherent actions – to the four elements of the business model, which…
Every business model rests on assumptions about the world it operates in. The trouble starts when those business model assumptions stop being recognisable as assumptions and quietly turn into certainties. This post begins with Drucker’s account of that mechanism, then shows two sets of assumptions failing under measurement in a single year: the geopolitical order that supplied us with energy,…
The AI@Strategy Conference 2026 takes place in Munich on 7 and 8 October, organised by the Chair for Strategy and Organization at TUM School of Management. This post describes what the programme covers, names five sessions I find worth attending, and argues that its subject throughout is the organisation rather than the business model. Education is the main case: the…
This piece was first written in December 2025, when the debate about Novo Nordisk was still framed as a race for the better molecule. It has been rewritten with the figures from the half-year report of August 4, 2026, and with a different question at its centre. The question is not whether Novo was too slow. It is whether the…
Lately, I have spent far too much time thinking about meaningless corporate work: intelligent people producing perfect presentations, precise numbers and carefully aligned decisions—without anybody asking whether the work is relevant at all. Then AI arrived. It might liberate us from meaningless work. Or it might help us produce more of it, faster and with unprecedented precision. The idea for…
End of content
End of content